Did Yeshua Ever Become Unclean?
“If anyone is thirsty, let him come to Me and drink. Out of the one who trusts in Me will flow rivers of living water.” (John 7:37-38)
This study comes from a question. The individual who asked understands what we have been saying about Yeshua and holiness flowing out of Him. But there is always a “but.” How can we say that Yeshua was never made impure? How is this possible?
You could argue that He was a flesh-and-blood human being living under the Torah. He touched the dead. He stood next to people who were unclean. He spent His days surrounded by exactly the conditions that Leviticus says transmit impurity everywhere. So, if we take His humanity seriously—and we should—then He contracted impurity the way any of us would. And if He did, surely He went to the Temple and, through the Torah’s instruction, would have undergone the purification process necessary to walk into holy space. It is a good question.
And guess what? We are not going to get a final answer to it today. This is the beginning of another series on impurity. The answer truly will only be found when our Messiah comes and explains it all.
But before you decide that not having an answer makes the whole thing pointless, this is a very Jewish way to study: ask a real question, enter through the text, chase it to find the answer, and come out on the other side. Sometimes we have the issue tied up; a lot of times we do not. The goal is not to win an argument. The goal is to read the Gospel with a curiosity you may not have previously brought to your reading, and to come away seeing how much is actually going on beneath the surface.
The Machinery of Impurity
We already know the machinery from our work on the forces of death and impurity: impurity is bound up with death, corpses, disease, and the loss of lifeblood. Impurity moves—it travels from the unclean to the clean by contact. That is the nature of impurity: you touch the source, and you carry it away with you.
Now think of some of the places Yeshua actually spent His time. He takes the hand of a dead girl. He touches the funeral bier. He stands at the mouth of the tomb where Lazarus has been for four days—long enough that his sister Martha mentions the smell. There is a woman who has bled for twelve years, and she pushes through the packed crowd and touches His garment. By law, everyone she interacted with and touched became impure. A man with biblical leprosy approaches—by law, he should have been outside the camp somewhere, calling out “unclean” as he knelt before the leper. Yet Yeshua reaches out His hand and touches him.
So by the plain mechanics of the law, every one of those encounters should leave Yeshua impure. But that is not what happens. The dead girl wakes up. The man on the funeral bier sits up and speaks. Lazarus walks out of the tomb. The woman is healed in an instant, and Mark tells us Yeshua felt the power go out from Him. The man’s leprosy leaves him—he is clean. In every case, impurity should flow from the source out, the way it always does—from the dead and the diseased to the living and the well. But in every case, it goes the other way: life, healing, and cleansing pouring out of Yeshua.
The easy answer is: “He did not care about all that stuff. He is the Son of God—why would you even ask that question?” But we are going to move past that dismissal for a ton of reasons, given what we know about Yeshua, the Temple, Judaism, and Torah.
Two Things Impurity Cannot Overcome
In Jewish thought, there are examples of some holy things that cannot become impure. You bring impurity near, and nothing transfers. I want to show you two of them, and then we will look at Yeshua again through this lens.
1. Living Water — Mayim Chayim
There is a passage in Leviticus we could easily read right past. In the middle of a section about a carcass—which contaminates everything it touches: jars, ovens, food, water sitting in a pot—there is one exception. A spring or a gathering system of water stays clean. The very thing that defiles everything around it cannot touch that kind of water. The distinction is this: if you draw water off into a vessel, that is different. But water still joined to its source—groundwater or a spring system—that kind of natural mayim holds its purity.
Living water was part of everyday life in Israel. Of course, when you go to the Temple, you see rows of mikvot everywhere. You immersed before going up to the Temple. A woman immersed after her monthly cycle. A man immersed after his own forms of impurity. People were always going into that water. What happens? They go down impure and come up pure—yet the water stays pure. Someone else can go in right after them. There is no purification process required for the water. So who wins between the unclean and the water? The water wins!
2. The Word of the Lord — The Torah
A student is studying with his teacher when he suddenly stops, embarrassed. He realizes that he is ritually impure and feels he has no business speaking holy words of Torah in that condition. His teacher tells him, “Open your mouth, let the words shine, because the words of Torah do not contract impurity.” He proves this from Jeremiah 23:9, where Jeremiah says that God’s word is like fire. Just as fire cannot be made unclean—if you take something impure and throw it into fire, the fire burns it up, the impurities are consumed, and the flame remains pure—so too, when impurity comes near the words of Torah, God’s word finds nothing to take hold of.
This later becomes a matter of Jewish law regarding the Torah scroll. A scroll may be handled by a ritually impure person, a menstruating woman, and even unredeemed individuals—the point is that even very high levels of impurity do not defile the scroll. The system was designed to keep people at a distance from holy things, yet they may pick up a scroll and read from it.
So we have two things: living water, which cleanses and cannot be defiled, and the word of the Lord, which cannot be contaminated by impurity. Impurity cannot take hold of either water or word.
The Word Made Flesh, the Living Water
Now turn to the Gospel of John. It opens with a strange, almost cryptic passage: “In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. The Word became flesh and dwelt among us” (John 1:1, 14). The Greek word logos carried deep meaning in the Jewish world of the first century, especially through the Aramaic concept of Memra—the Word. In Jewish understanding, when the Scriptures were read in the synagogue, when God acts, when God creates, when God speaks, the text repeatedly refers to this as the word of the Lord—God’s own presence and action in the world. That is the category John is referencing and expanding upon when he points to Yeshua.
And Yeshua is also the source of living water. At the Feast of Tabernacles, the priest performs the great water-drawing ceremony. They go down to the Pool of Siloam, fill a golden vessel with water, and carry it to the Temple in a joyful procession, pouring it out on the altar. John tells us that on the last great day of the festival, in the middle of all of this, Yeshua stood up and said, “If anyone is thirsty, let him come to me and drink. Out of the one who trusts in me will flow rivers of living water” (John 7:37-38).
He is offering living water—the very thing that cleanses and remains pure—and He is standing in the middle of the Temple during a celebration of water.
And remember the woman at the well—the Samaritan woman (John 4). He offered her living water, a spring welling up to eternal life. And He offered it to a Samaritan, who would certainly be considered impure. The disciples did not even want Him talking to her, yet the offer was made and fully received, and she was fully cleansed, while Yeshua maintained His purity!
Here is the connection: the two things in Scripture that impurity cannot overcome—the Word and living water—are the very images John uses to describe Yeshua. The Word made flesh, the living water flowing out of Him.
The Faithful, Torah-Keeping Jew
So back to the question: Did Yeshua become impure? Drumroll, please.
There is a second question hiding in the first. If He did not become impure, does that mean He never kept the purity laws—never brought sacrifices for impurity, never went to the mikveh, and so on?
Here is something to think about, especially for the critic who would wave all of this off and say, “Of course He was never subject to that impurity nonsense—He did not do that legalism!” Remember what we learned about the tzaddik—the righteous one. One thing we always find is true: the tzaddik is with his people. He identifies with them. He does not hold himself above them; He is down in the middle with them.
Now think about who Yeshua was understood to be—the Messiah of Israel. A teacher with students, living in public, constantly watched, and measured against everything the people expected of a faithful Son of the covenant. The Messiah of Israel was never imagined as someone who would put an end to the Torah or brush it aside—contrary to what you might have been taught somewhere along the way (Matthew 5:17-18). That is not what “fulfill” means. If anything, He was expected to live more faithfully than anyone alive.
So if He had carried Himself as a man who stood above Torah, who treated the purity laws as beneath Him because He was too “pure” to be touched by them, that would not have marked Him as Israel’s Messiah. It would have done the opposite—it would have disqualified Him in the eyes of the people and the teachers.
Look at the handwashing dispute. The Pharisees come and ask, “Why do Your disciples eat with unwashed hands, breaking the tradition?” They ask about the disciples—they never ask why He does not wash (Matthew 15:2). And remember, that was not even a command from the Torah; it was a fence around the Torah to wash before eating. Yet even here, we see the accusation goes right around Him. He kept the practices of the people.
And look at what He does when He cleanses the man with tzara’at. What does Yeshua tell him? “Go and offer the sacrifice for your cleansing.” He sends the man into the Torah’s prescribed procedures. He does not say, “Do not worry about all that—you have been close enough to Me.” He honored the Torah way.
Now this can make more sense to us in the scene at the Jordan River, when Yeshua comes to be immersed. John says, “Wow, what are You doing? I should be baptized by You!” And Yeshua answers: “Let it be so now, to fulfill all righteousness” (Matthew 3:15). He steps into the water and stands with the people in the same water—all those who needed baptism for repentance. He did not need that, but the same instinct carried Him to the mikveh, to the Temple, through the purifications.
So can we say He kept the purification laws anyway—went down to the mikveh, went up to the Temple—for the sake of His people and His mission? The Gospels never tell us; they are simply not interested in settling that for us. But everything about the way He carried Himself says very likely. He would have done every bit of it, even if impurity never could touch Him, because faithful identification with the people demanded it—the way it always had.
Conclusion: Magnifying Our Savior
So is our question settled? Unfortunately, this is not one of those times where we can give a definitive answer. The answer is what we said at the beginning: we will know when Messiah comes and explains it all.
This is not a hill to die on anyway. But as I love to do, it gives you some food for thought—maybe something you never even considered—and content for discussion, especially with people who would think you are crazy for even asking the question.
One more amazing thing to consider about Yeshua: the One out of whom living water flows, the Word made flesh, the Master over the forces of death—and a faithful, Torah-keeping, Temple-honoring Jew, the Messiah of Israel and the cosmos. It is just one more way to get more out of the Gospels than words on a page.
He is even more amazing than we have considered!
“The LORD, the LORD, a God merciful and gracious, slow to anger, abounding in steadfast love and faithfulness.” (Exodus 34:6)
May you see Yeshua in all His fullness: the Word made flesh, the Living Water, the faithful Son who identifies with His people.
Light In Torah 
Leave a comment